Skip to content 
Tub-to-Shower Conversion: A Case Study in Fishers, IN
Project Overview
- Customer: Michelle
- Location: Fishers, Hamilton County, IN
- Contractor: Superior Bath System
The Summary
- The Challenge: Michelle had a standard, uninspired fiberglass tub-and-shower combo that was monopolizing her bathroom space. Between the high step-in barrier and the notoriously clingy shower curtain, her daily routine felt less like a spa day and more like a hurdle event.
- The Solution: A full tub-to-shower conversion featuring a sleek, low-threshold shower pan, modern grey faux-tile wall panels, a premium dual-showerhead system, and sliding glass doors.
- The Outcome: A spacious, modern, and accessible shower that seamlessly fits into her vibrantly painted bathroom, maximizing both safety and style without requiring a total room demolition.
The Hoosier Context
Living in Fishers, Indiana, means you get the best of all four seasons—which also means you need a bathroom that can help you thaw out after a freezing Hoosier winter, or wash off the humidity after a summer afternoon walking around the Nickel Plate District or boating on Geist Reservoir. Michelle’s old, cramped tub just wasn’t cutting it for a relaxing, luxurious soak or a quick, refreshing rinse. It was time for a Superior upgrade.
Project Deep Dive: The Nitty Gritty
What problem did the homeowner have?
Michelle’s primary issues were accessibility, aesthetics, and maintenance. The existing one-piece fiberglass tub had a high threshold, creating a daily tripping hazard. Furthermore, the space felt closed off by a standard shower curtain. While her mint-green walls were wonderfully vibrant and fun, the bulky white tub unit paired with the flimsy waffle curtain made the space feel distinctly “builder-grade 1990s.” She wanted something more elegant and breathable.
What solution and materials were used?
The team at Superior Bath System performed a stunning tub-to-shower conversion. The materials included:
- A Low-Profile Shower Pan: Bright white and highly durable, making stepping in and out a breeze.
- Acrylic Wall Surrounds: Designed to mimic large, modern grey tiling. Because it’s a solid surface rather than actual porous grout, it’s incredibly easy to clean and naturally resists mold and mildew.
- Sliding Glass Doors: High-quality, clear glass with sleek brushed hardware to open up the room visually.
- Upgraded Fixtures: A versatile brushed-nickel dual showerhead (fixed head plus a handheld wand) and integrated corner shelving caddies for organized storage.
If you are looking to ditch the tub altogether, checking out modern replacement showers like this is the perfect starting point!
What was the biggest challenge in this project?
Looking closely at the “Before” photo, the biggest challenge was the surgical removal of the old unit. One-piece fiberglass tubs are notoriously difficult to extract, especially when the homeowner has flawlessly painted drywall immediately adjacent to the unit. The Superior Bath System crew had to carefully dismantle and remove the bulky old tub, re-route the plumbing drain from a tub configuration to a center shower pan configuration, and install the new track system—all without scuffing Michelle’s pristine green paint job!
What are the most obvious gains in the project?
- Enhanced Safety (ADA-Friendly Elements): The most critical gain is the dramatic reduction in the threshold height. Removing the high tub wall practically eliminates the risk of slips and falls when entering or exiting the shower.
- Effortless Cleaning: Goodbye, scrubbing! The smooth, grout-free wall panels mean Michelle will spend far less time battling soap scum and more time actually enjoying her bathroom.
- Spaciousness & Light: By swapping an opaque curtain for clear sliding glass doors, the light from the vanity now reaches the back of the shower, making the entire bathroom feel twice as large.
